Should have Sire de Grugy kept the tingle creek after cutting across Special Tiara? I would like to know everyones thoughts on the matter I think the decision was correct, I am aware that the special tiara team may appeal aswell so whats everyones opinion on that?

its a bit like the leger tough call i personally think SDG would have still won Tara had time to get back up
will be watching closely to see how the appeal goes

I agree completely. I hope Sire De Grugy keeps the race.

Think Special Tiara should get it, yes he had time to get past but he got knocked sideways which would have took a lot out of him. I also think he would have landed in front if not for the interference. He wont win it thought because you cant get a race getting bumper a yard from the line so what chance has he got. The problem is the rules are wrong.

Unfortunately its impossible to say if Tiara would have won, he was closing at the last but it is guess work as to the final result without interference. I don't agree with many that say Tiara had plenty of time to get back up. He had a massive bump and was lucky to keep his footing and not fall, Incidents like that or a blunder at a fence can take a lot out of a horse as well as perhaps denting the horses confidence.

As I said its impossible to reach a decision so I think the result should stand, obviously Tiara was extremely unlucky.